The Dichotomy of Filial Responsibilities: A Closer Look at Family Dynamics in India

Introduction

In India, family is the cornerstone of society. Deeply rooted in tradition and culture, Indian families are known for their close-knit bonds and interdependence. One prominent aspect of this familial structure is the expectation that the married woman, as the daughter-in-law, will support and care for her in-laws. While this tradition has been upheld for generations, there is an undeniable dichotomy in the way Indian women approach their responsibilities towards their own parents versus their in-laws. This blog explores this issue, delving into the reasons behind this complex dynamic and discussing potential solutions.

Understanding the Cultural Context

To truly understand the issue at hand, it is essential to grasp the cultural context of India. Family values are deeply ingrained in the Indian psyche, with the joint family system being a prevalent model. In such families, it is common for the parents of the married man to live with their son and his wife. This arrangement is considered not just a tradition but a moral obligation, as children are expected to take care of their aging parents.

The Role of the Daughter-in-Law

The daughter-in-law, in this scenario, plays a pivotal role. She is expected to not only fulfill her duties as a wife but also act as a caregiver to her in-laws. This includes tasks such as cooking, cleaning, and tending to their needs. It is viewed as her responsibility to ensure the well-being and comfort of her husband's parents.

The Dichotomy

However, a significant issue arises when we examine how Indian women often prioritize their own parents over their in-laws, especially in times of need. While they are expected to provide care and support to their husband's family, it is frequently observed that the level of care and attention they give to their own parents far surpasses that given to their in-laws.

Why Does This Dichotomy Exist?

Several factors contribute to this apparent dichotomy in filial responsibilities:

Emotional Attachment: One of the primary reasons behind this behavior is the strong emotional bond that women share with their own parents. This connection is often seen as more profound and enduring than their relationship with their in-laws. Naturally, when their own parents face health or financial issues, women are more emotionally inclined to offer support.

Distance: In many cases, a woman's parents live separately, often in another city or town. This physical separation can create a sense of urgency and responsibility when her parents are in need. In contrast, her in-laws may be living under the same roof, and their issues might not appear as pressing.

Societal Expectations: Society, too, has a role to play in reinforcing this dichotomy. Traditional gender roles and familial expectations have conditioned women to prioritize their own parents over their in-laws. This societal pressure can make it challenging for women to navigate their responsibilities effectively.

Fear of Conflict: Women may fear that if they prioritize their own parents over their in-laws over, it could lead to conflicts within the family. This fear of upsetting the familial balance can result in women silently shouldering the burden of caring for their in-laws while secretly wishing they could do more for their own parents.

Addressing the Issue

While it is essential to recognize the factors contributing to this dichotomy, it is equally crucial to find ways to address the issue constructively:

Open Communication: Families should encourage open and honest communication about filial responsibilities. This includes discussing expectations, needs, and the emotional aspects of caregiving. Creating a safe space for these conversations can help bridge the gap.

Equal Partnership: Husbands play a crucial role in balancing the caregiving responsibilities. They should actively participate in taking care of their parents and share the burden with their wives. An equal partnership can reduce the pressure on women.

Support from In-Laws: In-laws should also play a role in easing the burden on their daughters-in-law. They can actively express their understanding of the emotional attachment women have with their own parents and encourage a balanced approach to caregiving.

Community and Government Initiatives: Communities and governments can offer support through initiatives that provide caregivers with resources, respite care, and counseling. These measures can help women fulfill their responsibilities without feeling overwhelmed.

Changing Gender Roles: Society needs to evolve its perception of gender roles and familial responsibilities. Encouraging women to prioritize their own parents when necessary should not be seen as neglecting their duties as daughters-in-law.

Conclusion

The dichotomy of filial responsibilities between caring for one's own parents and in-laws in Indian families is a complex issue rooted in tradition, culture, and societal expectations. While it is essential to acknowledge the emotional bonds and challenges that contribute to this dichotomy, it is equally crucial to work towards a more balanced and equitable approach to caregiving. Open communication, equal partnership, and support from both sides of the family can go a long way in addressing this issue. Ultimately, the goal should be to foster an environment where women can fulfill their responsibilities to all their loved ones without feeling torn between conflicting expectations.

C. P. Kumar
Reiki Healer & Former Scientist 'G', National Institute of Hydrology
Roorkee - 247667, India

Reiki Healing: https://reiki-roorkee.blogspot.com/
Web: https://www.angelfire.com/nh/cpkumar/virgo.html
Spiritual and Social Books: https://amazon.com/author/cpkumar/